
NFF & CHF National High School Scholar-Athletes
| 2009 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Brenton Caprio | Mainland Regional | South Jersey Chapter |
| John Gilboy | Thornton Academy | State of Maine Chapter |
| Matt Lancaster | West Lafayette | Joe Tiller/Northwest Indiana Chapter |
| Gavin Mills | Powell | Wyoming Chapter |
| Jamal-Rashad Patterson | Henry County | Greater Atlanta Chapter |
| 2008 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Nick Downey | Mundelein | Chicago Metro |
| Jordan Haynes | Jesuit | Sacramento Valley |
| Andrew Luck | Stratford | Touchdown Club of Houston |
| Johnathan Meyers | Greenwich | Ralph DeSantis |
| Andrew Rodriguez | Bishop Ireton | National Captial Region (D.C.) |
| 2007 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Ryan Coffey | Burrillville | Rhode Island |
| Barton Dear | Klein Oak | Touchdown Club of Houston |
| Kellen Killsgaard | Auburn | King County (Seattle, Wash.) |
| Blake Lawrence | Shawnee Mission West | Sunflower (Topeka, Kan.) |
| Matthew Stotler | Yorktown | National Captial Region (D.C.) |
| 2006 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Bryant Browning | Glenville Academic Center | Northeast Ohio |
| Barry Charles Gallup, Jr. | Belmont | Eastern Massachusetts |
| Christopher LaTempa | Pequannock Township | Morris County of New Jersey |
| Kevin McCarthy, Jr. | Plant | Tampa |
| Christopher Prosinski | Buffalo | Wyoming |
| 2005 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| David M. Miller | Norco | Riverside County |
| Thomas Bemenderfer | Penn | Moose Krause |
| Brandon Chase Fisher | Christ Presbyterian Academy | Middle Tennessee |
| Ramsey R. Lafayette | Hampden Academy | State of Maine |
| 2004 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Marcus Monk | East Poinsett County | Arkansas |
| Christopher Pizzoti | Reading Memorial | Eastern Massachusetts |
| Dusty Reddick | Screven County | Greater Atlanta |
| Jake Wheeler | Laguna Beach | Orange County |
| 2003 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Matthew Barbour | Grossmont | Walter Zable/San Diego |
| Brandent Englemon | Holmes | Greater Cincinnati |
| Joe Watson | Greenville | Tri-Cities |
| Peter Wood | St. John's | Joe Mewhiney/Central Mass. |
| 2002 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Matthew Hostetler | River Hill | Greater Baltimore |
| Connor Hughes | Lafayette | Commonwealth |
| Greg Rommel | Henninger | Central New York |
| Jacob William Stone | Limon | Colorado |
| Justin Zwick | Masillon Washington | Northeastern Ohio |
| 2001 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Matt Anderson | Fergus | Montana |
| Maurice Hall | Brookhaven | Columbus, OH |
| Adam Jenkins | Burlington | Eastern Massachusetts |
| John Rote | Briarcrest Christian | Memphis |
| 2000 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Jeremy Caudill | Prestonsburg | Jerry Claiborne |
| Timothy Kirby | Junipero Serra | Northern California |
| William Wesley McConnell | Ruston | S.M. McNaughton |
| Joe Weiss | Mainland Regional | South Jersey |
| 1999 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Bryan Blew | Edmond North | Oklahoma |
| Willy Davidson | Huntley Project | Montana |
| Micah Kimball | Fonda-Fultonville | Capital District |
| Robert Shirley | Buffalo Gap | Central Virginia |
| 1998 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Drew Henson | Brighton | Michigan |
| Marc Laborsky | DePaul Regional | Passaic County |
| Blake Moore | Ogden | Utah |
| Jon Stinchcomb | Parkview | Greater Atlanta & Univ. of GA |
| 1997 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Freeman Belser | Heathwood Hall Episcopal | Midland |
| Todd Mortenson | Tempe | Valley of the Sun |
| Brian Sponheimer | Notre Dame | Gene Casey / New Haven County |
| Brandon Wier | Olathe North | Sunflower |
| 1996 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Justin Hopkin | Burlington | Wyoming |
| Jefferson Kelley | Colerain | Greater Cincinnati |
| Brendan Panda | Fairfield Prep | Gene Casey / New Haven County |
| Will Rote | Briarcrest | Memphis |
| 1995 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Justin Brown | Newport | Arkansas |
| Giovanni Carmazzi | Jesuit | Sacramento Valley |
| Tommy Rhyne | Westlake | Greater Austin |
| Rich Stankewicz | Henderson | Philadelphia |
| 1994 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Stephen Alexander | Chickasha | Oklahoma |
| Matthew James DeOrio | The Bolles School | North Florida |
| Matthew Rothe | Fort Morgan | Colorado |
| David Matthew Rader | Pennsbury | Delaware Valley |
| 1993 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Tim Booth | Catholic | Capital City |
| Ryan Daniels | St. John's | Toledo |
| Eion Hu | DePaul | Passaic County |
| Randy Lund | Western | Las Vegas |
| 1992 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Eric Adams | La Jolla County Day | Walter Zable/San Diego |
| Todd Helton | Knoxville Central | East Tennessee/Knoxville |
| Quinterol Mallette | Plainfield | Southeastern Connecticut |
| Kevin Mayer | St. Ignatius | Northeastern Ohio |
| 1991 | ||
| Scholar-Athlete | High School | Chapter |
| Joel England | Camp Verde | Valley of the Sun |
| Paul Glagola | Middletown | Greater Baltimore |
| Jonathan Gibson | Eupora | Ole Miss |
| Robert Hoying | St. Henry | Dayton |